Chamber of Discovery
An astounding find in South Africa adds a new branch to the human family tree.
The first clue was a skull spotted by amateur cavers as they descended deep beneath the ground of South Africa.
Before long, an international team of scientists, including a UW paleoanthropologist, undertook a remarkable task, bringing to light an unprecedented trove of fossils — more than fifteen hundred well-preserved bones and teeth that represent the largest, most complex set of such remains found to date on the continent.
They weren’t just any old bones. Writing in two scientific papers published in September, the scientists revealed that the discovery adds a new branch to the human family tree, a creature they dubbed Homo naledi.
And there’s more: the fossils — first discovered in 2013 in a barely accessible chamber, a labyrinth one hundred feet underground not far from Johannesburg — could only have been deliberately deposited, a behavior by these very early human ancestors that suggests culture. It’s a supposition akin to discovering similar activities among chimpanzees, says John Hawks, a UW professor of anthropology and one of the team’s leaders. “It would be that surprising,” he says.
15 At least this many skeletons — representing all ages — were found within a chamber of the limestone caves near the Cradle of Humankind.
150 The approximate number of countries with readers who clicked to view a UW website that launched when the Homo naledi story went public in September.
When announced to the world, the discovery sparked international interest and was covered by National Geographic (the project’s main funder), 60 Minutes, the Guardian, Slate, National Public Radio, the New York Times, the BBC, and many other news outlets.
So far, parts of at least fifteen skeletons representing individuals of all ages have been found, and the researchers, led by paleoanthropologist Lee R. Berger of the University of Witwatersrand, believe many more fossils remain. The chamber is part of a complex of limestone caves near what is called the Cradle of Humankind, a World Heritage Site in Gauteng province well known for critical discoveries of early humans, including the 1947 discovery of 2.3 million-year-old Australopithecus africanus.
“We have a new species of Homo, with all of its interesting characteristics,” says Hawks, adding that the find is the “biggest discovery in Africa for hominins,” a subfamily of the taxonomic system that includes humans.
The Rewards of Being Small
The Facebook query was exacting and cryptic: “We need perhaps three or four individuals with excellent archaeological / paleontological excavation skills. … The catch is this — the person must be skinny and preferably small. They must not be claustrophobic, they must be fit, they should have some caving experience, climbing experience would be a bonus …”
Alia Gurtov MS’13, a UW anthropology graduate student, fit the bill. Read more »
Homo naledi — with a small head and brain, hunched shoulders, powerful hands, and thin limbs — was built for long-distance walking, says Hawks, an expert on early humans. Fully grown, it stood about five feet tall, was broad chested, walked upright, and had a face that included a smile that was probably more human than apelike. The powerful hands imply that it was also a climber.
The fossils have yet to be dated. The unmineralized condition of the bones and the geology of the cave have prevented an accurate estimate, says Hawks. “They could have been there 2 million years ago or 100,000 years ago, possibly coexisting with modern humans. We don’t yet have a date, but we’re attempting it in every way we can.
“We depend on the geology to help us date things, and here the geology isn’t much like other caves in South Africa,” he continues. “And the fossils don’t have anything within them that we can date. It’s a problem for us.”
One hope, he says, is finding the remains of an animal that may have been a contemporary of Homo naledi. The fossils are embedded in a matrix of soft sediment and there are layers that remain unexcavated.
The remains represent newborns to the aged. The researchers expect that many more bones are yet to be exhumed from the chamber, which is accessible only after squeezing, clambering, and crawling six hundred feet to a large space where the brittle fossils cover the floor.
“We know about every part of the anatomy, and they are not at all like humans,” says Hawks, who co-directed the analysis of the fossils. “We couldn’t match them to anything that exists. It is clearly a new species.”
Naledi means star in Sesotho and refers to the Rising Star cave system that includes the Dinaledi Chamber, where the fossils were found. The circuitous and difficult passage to the chamber narrows at one point to a mere seven inches. The fossils were retrieved by a group of paleoanthropologists who were recruited in part for their diminutive size.
In addition to identifying an entirely new species in the genus Homo, the fossils, which bear no marks from predators or scavengers, are strong evidence that Homo naledi were deliberately interring their dead. “We think it is the first instance of deliberate and ritualized interment,” says Hawks. “The only plausible scenario is they deliberately put bodies in this place.”
The cave, he says, was likely more accessible to Homo naledi than it is for modern humans. Geochemical tests, however, show that it was never open to the surface, raising intriguing questions about the behavior and technologies available to Homo naledi. “We know it was not a death trap,” Hawks says, referring to natural features such as hidden sink holes that sometimes trap and doom creatures over long periods of time. “There are no bones from animals, aside from a few rodents. And there are no marks on the bones from predators or scavengers to suggest they were killed and dragged to the chamber. We can also rule out that it was a sudden mass death.”
Instead, Hawks, Berger, and their colleagues believe that the chamber was a place where Homo naledi routinely secreted their dead companions. The way the bodies are arranged and the completeness of the skeletons suggest they were carried to the cave intact. “It seems probable that a group of hominins was returning to this place over a period of time and depositing bodies,” Hawks says. “The bodies were not intentionally covered, and we’re not talking about a religious ceremony, but something that was repeated and repeated in the same place. They clearly learned to do this and did it as a group over time. That’s cultural. Only humans and close relatives like Neandertals do anything like this.”
The team has yet to find other organic materials or evidence of fire in the cave complex.
Hawks says plans include calling upon many new technologies to analyze the fossils, helping to determine diet, rate of aging, and Homo naledi ’s home region.
Years of work remain both on and off site. The researchers will continue to excavate new materials and carefully analyze the remarkable find, unlocking secrets of a long-ago human ancestor.